5 Reasons to Keep the Electoral College
Every time the Electoral College and the national popular vote point in different directions, as they did in 2000 and 2016, calls to abolish it grow louder. But the system has prominent defenders among legal scholars, historians and political scientists, who argue it does things a national popular vote cannot.
Here are the five main arguments for keeping the Electoral College, drawn from the scholars and judges who have made the case. (For the opposing view, see 5 Reasons to Abolish the Electoral College.)
Key Takeaways
- Defenders say the Electoral College is a pillar of American federalism, alongside the U.S. Senate.
- It requires a winning candidate to carry states across multiple regions, not just run up the vote in a few.
- It usually turns a narrow popular vote win into a clear electoral majority, reducing disputes over legitimacy.
- It confines recounts and fraud disputes to individual states instead of the entire country.
1. It Protects American Federalism
The most fundamental argument for the Electoral College is that it is woven into the United States’ federal structure, which divides power between the national government and the states. The Constitution creates the Electoral College, but it leaves each state legislature to decide how its electors are chosen. Presidential elections are, in a real sense, 51 separate contests — one in each state and the District of Columbia. (For how that process works, see How Are Electors Chosen?)
Historian Allen Guelzo, writing in National Affairs in 2018, argued that the Electoral College cannot be separated from federalism. If the principle that states matter in presidential elections is discarded, he wrote, the same logic would call the U.S. Senate into question, since senators represent whole states regardless of population. States would also lose one of their main sources of influence in national affairs, because electoral votes are the units in which presidential power is won.
Guelzo warned that abandoning the system would push the United States toward the kind of fragmented, multiparty elections common in parliamentary democracies. (Read more about the purpose of the Electoral College.)
2. It Reflects the Framers’ Design for Slow, Stable Government
Defenders of the Electoral College often return to the debates at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, where delegates rejected both direct election by the people and selection by Congress. The result was a compromise that gave both large and small states a stake in choosing the president. (See Why Was the Electoral College Created?)
Harvard Law Professor Charles Fried, a former U.S. solicitor general, has argued that states act as filters in national politics. Regional voting blocs shift as parties and regions change, but those shifts take hold over decades rather than swinging wildly from one election to the next. In Fried’s view, the Electoral College has survived political turmoil, a civil war and enormous social change precisely because it represents state interests and guards against outlier movements.
Guelzo adds that the Constitution was never meant to move quickly. Its checks and balances divide power among the executive, legislative and judicial branches, and staggered terms — six years for senators, four for presidents, two for House members — keep any single election from remaking the government overnight. In his telling, the framers built deliberate, indirect institutions to temper the impulses of a pure direct democracy. Alexander Hamilton made a version of that case in Federalist No. 68, describing the electors as a safeguard in choosing the chief executive. (For the full backstory, see A Brief Electoral College History.)
3. It Forces Candidates to Build National Coalitions
Supporters argue the Electoral College requires a winning candidate to assemble support across many regions rather than piling up votes in a few populous areas.
Federal appeals judge Richard Posner made this case in a widely cited 2012 Slate article, arguing that the system helps produce “everyone’s president.” No single region has enough electoral votes to elect a president on its own, Posner noted, so voters in one part of the country need not fear being governed by a candidate who appealed only to another. He also argued that the focus on closely contested battleground states — sometimes called purple states — has a benefit: voters in those states pay the closest attention to the campaign and are, in his view, the most thoughtful voters. (See our current list of battleground states.)
Constitutional scholar Ronald Rotunda made a related argument in a 2000 essay for the Cato Institute. Every state, no matter how small, is guaranteed at least three electoral votes. Today six states — Alaska, Delaware, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont and Wyoming — and the District of Columbia have three each, and in a close race any of them can be decisive. Rotunda argued that under a national popular vote, those voters would be ignored entirely.
Rotunda also contended that the system amplifies the influence of Black and Hispanic voters, who are heavily concentrated in large states with big electoral vote totals. Because those voters can swing a state’s entire slate of electors, he argued, both parties have strong reasons to court them.
4. It Produces Clear and Decisive Outcomes
Defenders say the Electoral College almost always delivers a clear winner — and contains the damage when a race is close.
At a 2008 MIT conference on the Electoral College, SUNY Cortland political scientist Judith Best warned that a close national popular vote could produce “50 Floridas,” a reference to the recount fight after the 2000 presidential election. Under the current system, a dispute is usually confined to one or two states. Under a national popular vote, a razor-thin margin could trigger recounts and lawsuits in every state at once. “A swift, sure decision is more important than a decision that is 100 percent accurate,” Best said.
That risk isn’t hypothetical. James Garfield won the national popular vote in 1880 by fewer than 2,000 votes out of more than 9 million cast, and John F. Kennedy’s national margin in 1960 was less than two-tenths of a percentage point. In both cases the Electoral College produced a clear result.
Posner also pointed out that the electoral vote margin almost always exceeds the popular vote margin, which makes ties and disputed outcomes rare. Bill Clinton won just 43% of the popular vote in 1992 but 370 electoral votes. Richard Nixon won 43.4% in 1968 but a clear electoral majority. In 2024, Donald Trump won the popular vote with 49.8% — a plurality, not a majority — but carried 312 electoral votes. Without the Electoral College, Posner argued, the country would likely need a runoff whenever no candidate won a majority, and presidents elected with 43% could face serious questions about their mandate.
Peter Wallison of the American Enterprise Institute extended that argument in 2016. He wrote that the Electoral College confers legitimacy by producing an electoral majority for the winner, even when no one wins a majority of the popular vote. Under a pure popular vote, Wallison warned, single-issue parties and spoiler candidates could crowd the ballot, and “we could easily end up with a president elected with only 20 percent-25 percent of the vote.”
5. A National Popular Vote Has Its Own Pitfalls
Many arguments for keeping the Electoral College focus on the weaknesses of the alternative.
Guelzo and other defenders note that the United States was designed as a constitutional republic, not a pure democracy. They also argue that the principle of “one person, one vote” comes from Supreme Court decisions — Gray v. Sanders (1963) and Reynolds v. Sims (1964), which applied to state and local elections — rather than from any provision of the Constitution governing presidential elections.
Attorney Tara Ross, in a 2004 essay for the Heritage Foundation, argued that the Electoral College acts as a firewall against fraud. Because votes are tallied state by state, fraudulent ballots in one state can affect only that state’s electors, and only if the race there is close. Under a national popular vote, she argued, stolen votes anywhere would count everywhere, and the room for recounts, lawsuits and disputes over legitimacy would expand dramatically.
Finally, Fried responded to critics who want direct elections for president by pointing out that Americans already practice direct democracy at the state and local level. Voters choose their school board members, city councilors, state legislators and governors by popular vote. Supporters of the Electoral College see that balance — direct elections close to home and a state-based system for the presidency — as the essence of federalism.
Could the Electoral College Be Changed Without an Amendment?
Abolishing the Electoral College would require a constitutional amendment, which has repeatedly failed in Congress. (See our history of Electoral College reform efforts.) Popular vote supporters are instead pursuing the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which now includes 18 states and D.C. with 222 of the 270 electoral votes needed to take effect. Electoral College defenders argue the compact would sidestep the amendment process the framers required and would face legal challenges if it ever took effect.
Curious how the map would look under different rules? Try our interactive electoral map, or see what would happen if every state split its electoral votes like Maine and Nebraska.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do supporters want to keep the Electoral College?
Supporters say it protects federalism, forces candidates to win support across many regions, usually produces a clear winner, and limits recounts and fraud disputes to individual states.
Does the Electoral College help small states?
Every state is guaranteed at least three electoral votes, which gives the least populous states more electoral votes per resident. Critics counter that small states that aren’t competitive are still ignored by campaigns — see our argument that the Electoral College does not help small states.
What happens if no one wins 270 electoral votes?
The House of Representatives chooses the president, with each state delegation casting one vote. Learn more about what happens in an Electoral College tie.
What are the arguments for abolishing the Electoral College?
Critics say it lets the popular vote loser win, gives some votes more weight than others and confines campaigns to a handful of swing states. See 5 Reasons to Abolish the Electoral College.

